Two Festive Teas, Two Different Jobs
Organic Holiday Cheer and the Caffeinated Holiday Sampler both lean into warm holiday spices, but they solve different problems. One is a single oolong-based blend with a medium caffeine level; the other is a four-tin gift set of caffeinated teas. If you want one cozy cup for yourself, Holiday Cheer is the simpler choice. If you need a ready-to-give assortment, the sampler covers more ground.
The comparison below sticks to what the catalog confirms. Where a detail is not supplied—such as exact steep temperature for the sampler—I note it as a limitation rather than guessing.
What Each Product Actually Is
- Organic Holiday Cheer: Organic Holiday Cheer is an oolong tea blended with cinnamon, cloves, star anise, and anise essential oil; caffeine content is listed as medium. This tells you the base tea and the spice profile, and that it is not caffeine-free despite the cozy holiday framing.

Organic Holiday Cheer - Caffeinated Holiday Sampler: The Caffeinated Holiday Sampler contains four tins of loose leaf tea in a ready-to-gift gold box, plus 30 drawstring tea bags; the teas are Organic Orange Cinnamon Spice, Organic Masala Chai, Organic Mint Bliss, and Organic Holiday Cheer. You get variety and gifting packaging in one purchase, including a repeat of Holiday Cheer in sampler form.

Caffeinated Holiday Sampler
Caffeine, Flavor, and Format Side by Side
The biggest practical difference is caffeine. Holiday Cheer is medium-caffeine oolong. The sampler is explicitly caffeinated, and its four blends include black tea (Masala Chai), green tea (Mint Bliss), and oolong (Holiday Cheer), so the caffeine level varies by tin.
- Caffeine: Holiday Cheer: medium caffeine from oolong. Sampler: caffeinated, with a mix of tea types across four tins. If you need a caffeine-free holiday tea, neither product is confirmed as caffeine-free in the supplied information.
- Flavor range: Holiday Cheer is one spiced oolong with nutty, anise-forward notes. The sampler adds orange-cinnamon spice, masala chai, and mint bliss for four distinct cups.
- Format: Holiday Cheer comes as loose leaf in a 2 oz bag (approx. 30 servings) or a 1/2 lb bulk bag (approx. 120 servings). The sampler is four tins with approximately 5–7 servings per tin and 30 drawstring tea bags included.
- Gifting: The sampler arrives in a ready-to-gift gold box with tea bags for easy steeping. Holiday Cheer is sold as a bag, so you would need to package it yourself if giving it as a gift.
Brewing and Serving Details That Affect Your Choice
- Organic Holiday Cheer: For Organic Holiday Cheer, add 1–2 teaspoons of tea to 8 oz of boiling-temperature water and let it steep for 5–7 minutes; the catalog also recommends filtered water for best results. This gives you a clear starting point for brewing a single mug, and the filtered-water note is a simple quality step.
- Caffeinated Holiday Sampler: The Caffeinated Holiday Sampler includes 30 drawstring tea bags to help make the tea, and each tin holds approximately 5–7 servings. The bags make the sampler easier to share or gift, but the small per-tin yield means it is better for tasting than for stocking a large household.
Which One Fits Your Holiday Plan
Choose Organic Holiday Cheer if you want a single spiced oolong to brew by the mug, you are comfortable with medium caffeine, and you prefer to buy a larger bag for repeated cups. The 2 oz bag suits a first try; the 1/2 lb bulk bag makes more sense if you already know you like anise-forward blends.
Choose the Caffeinated Holiday Sampler if you need a gift that is ready to hand over, want to offer several flavors to guests, or are building a tasting moment. Keep in mind that all four teas are caffeinated, so it is not the right pick for an evening caffeine-free routine.
What the Catalog Does Not Confirm
The supplied information does not state a specific water temperature or steep time for the Caffeinated Holiday Sampler teas, so follow the general guidance on the tin or use the Holiday Cheer instructions as a reference only for that blend. Neither product is confirmed as caffeine-free, allergen-free, or suitable for a specific dietary need. If you are choosing a holiday tea gift for someone with caffeine sensitivity or allergies, check the packaging or contact the store before buying.



